Sunday, November 22, 2015

Congressman Dodge?

I believe I should run for public office. My wife does not agree, however. Neither does my bank account. But I do believe I would make a tremendously effective congressional leader.

The only problem I see with my candidacy is that I would do those things that I believe are in the best interests of my constituents and of the country writ large, rather than for my political career. Sadly, this will mean that as the whims of public opinion shift, I'll undoubtedly lose my job.

Still, I think I'll run for office someday. Maybe even someday soon if my wife lets me.

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

A Better Response to Events in Ukraine?

To me (and I acknowledge that I am no expert on foreign affairs) the US response to events in the Ukraine and Crimea seem to be completely wrong-headed. I'd love to hear what others think in response to this proposal.

Russia has direct political and strategic interest in the region. After all, it's only warm-water port, giving access to Mediterranean trade routes, is there. Having suffered from three tremendously damaging invasions onto its territory since 1812, the strategic defense ideal developed under the communist regime was to put buffer states between itself and potential invaders. Putin came of age while that was the dominant thought process.

As such, the US and European nations should have welcomed the Russian intervention in its sphere of influence as a means of protecting the interests of Ukraine and its own investment in Crimea. Once the situation had stabilized, with elections held in Ukraine on a new national government, the Russians would have been encouraged to withdraw. They could even have been given assurances that Nato nations would allow for a referendum on whether Crimea would stay with Ukraine, become independent, or go to Russia, but only after Russian troops returned to pre-crisis positions.

This sounds a little bit like the appeasement doctrine that allowed Hitler to take over Czechoslovakia, but I do not think it is. This faces realities in the region. Russia is just too strong for Ukraine to resist. The US is not going to go to war over Ukraine and Russia knows it. By proceeding in this way the force in Putin's moves would have been removed. His power and interests in the region would be acknowledged, but he would also need to adhere to the rights of nations and people in his region. And, this would put the processes of democracy, the processes we claim to value so highly, into the hands of the people on the scene.

But then, we could just be engaging in a continuation of the "Great Game" of European history that made lesser powers the pawns of others.

Thursday, February 27, 2014

How to Grow the Church

The culture of evangelicalism currently dominates the discussion of Christian faith and action in the United States. This culture lies behind passage of laws like the one Arizona governor Jan Brewer and the Kansas Senate wisely vetoed or ignored. These laws were intended to legalize discrimination against same sex couples for religious reasons. 

The notion that religious liberty is at stake, which thereby makes such laws necessary, is absurd. No one is forcing anyone opposed to same sex marriage for religious reasons to marry someone of the same gender. No one is being forced to give up dearly held religious convictions. Instead, homosexual couples are simply asking businesses to provide services that are normally rendered to any heterosexual couple -- whether they were of the same faith background or not.

The tragedy is that adherents and defenders of evangelical culture who promulgate such laws fail to recognize the destination toward which their social issues are directing the Church. The trajectory is definitely down toward marginalism and irrelevance. Christians are seen as insensitive and hatefully discriminatory. As a result, individuals who were either never at home in this culture or no longer comfortable within its confines continue to move steadily away from the Church.

I believe there is a better way to do and be church. I believe it is possible to be faithful to the apostolic, orthodox center of Christianity in a way that will see the Kingdom of God come alive within individuals, families and communities. I believe this Kingdom life will be joyfully experienced and expressed in heterosexual and homosexual individuals, families and communities resulting in a vibrant future for the Church in North America. For this future to be realized, believers must discard the dominant cultural norms of evangelicalism and reclaim the gospel.

The norms that evangelicalism holds dear include a literarily and historically uninformed theory of the inspiration of scripture. This is the approach that claims everything written in scripture is fact, is exactly what the good Lord meant to tell us and is completely historically accurate. Yet the insistence that the story of creation in Genesis 1 must be seen as historically factual tells believers and non-believers that critical, scientific thinking is unwelcome in the church. This is tantamount to saying that to be or become a follower of Christ, you must shut off your mind and discard the quantifiable, verifiable insights into the world that scientists have discovered, such as a genetic predisposition toward homosexuality. People realize the insistence that they stop using their brains is nonsense and naturally assume all the rest of it must be nonsense as well.

If the church is to grow, this faulty approach to scripture must be set aside. Instead, people must be encouraged to approach the Bible on its own terms. It is a collection of stories and reflections from people doing their best to describe God’s interaction with them and the world God created, not a factual, historical description of how God created. Since the language of scripture is often metaphorical and poetic as well as historical, it must be allowed to speak as metaphor and poetry as well as history. Yes, it is language that expresses truths, but those truths do not preclude the possibility that humanity can discover truths through scientific discovery. Suddenly, a tremendous barrier that keeps people out of the Kingdom of God falls allowing lives to be changed by the Gospel. Suddenly the Church is able to grow.

Another norm that the dominant Christian culture stresses is the weekly worship meeting. Featuring music and lecture usually led by at least one religious professional, these events occur within the walls of a specified building at a set time each week. For most believers, attending this meeting is church. Bible studies, or group meetings at other times are ancillary to church, but they in themselves are not church. These secondary meetings serve the goal of increasing attendance at church. And it is believed that for the church to grow, it must have more highly polished elements resulting in a better show, which enables the congregation to more easily enter the presence of the holy.

In a recent blog post, Donald Miller spoke of his dissatisfaction with this form of church. He was roundly criticized by denizens of the dominant church culture as selfish, unbiblical, and as likely not having experienced “good” worship. What the criticism betrays is the belief that church is what takes place in the set meeting time and place where the professionals lead from the stage and the rest are entertained and consume as an audience.

I believe the type of community Miller describes is the Church; and I know I am not alone in this belief. Like me, these people no longer wish to strain against the binding strictures of “proper” belief based upon a “proper” reading of scripture in the “proper” format at the “proper” time. I would like to leave that behind. I would much rather hold to the apostolic faith in the resurrection and work with a growing community to understand the implications for this belief in our day-to-day actions. I would like to share the Good News with those around me, inviting them into a community of faith that values nuance, individuality, historical inquiry, scientific discovery and depth of thought.

As Miller points out, the problem is that there is no money in this model of church. How could I be a religious professional within this paradigm when I cannot pay for food, clothing, a warm bed and a roof over my head? I would undoubtedly need to support myself with a different job. 

Ever since we met, this is the model of church for which my wife has expressed an affinity. It is the model I now believe I will feel most comfortable with; and I believe it is a model that vast numbers of unbelievers would feel most comfortable with. I trust that God will continue to work in my spirit and guide me into this if it is where God wants me to move. The only thing I am certain of is that remaining within the thought patterns and practices of the dominant evangelical Christian culture no longer satisfies me. As I said before, I believe I am not alone.

I see the Church of near future composed of people whose lives are full to overflowing with faith, hope and love. These are people who move through the world bearing the fruit of the Spirit, sharing the Gospel story as it comes from the Bible and as it has been manifested in their own lives. These are people who are in the community of faith even though they do not meet together regularly in the manner most commonly seen today. These are counter-cultural people who are daily growing in grace and love, advocating for faithful, godly actions on behalf of the poor and oppressed, the widow and the orphan. This is the Church that I intend to be part of. This is the body of Christ growing in the world he redeemed through incarnation, death and resurrection.


Who else wants in?

Wednesday, August 21, 2013

On "Why I Am A Creationist"

            I find it embarrassing to be identified as a Christian. This is rather unfortunate, seeing as how I am a minister in a decidedly Christian church, which means part of my job is to advertise my faith to others in the hopes of creating more Christians.
            When Virginia Heffernan posted her reflection on Yahoo News, Why I Am A Creationist, I found that she had summarized the reason I find being a theist so embarrassing. Heffernan was careful to acknowledge that people might think she was stupid, which is good, because I found her rationale stupid.
            In the post, an otherwise intelligent woman concluded that living in a world where God exists feels better than living in a world without God. Rather than engaging in the intellectually arduous task of making sense of apparently contradictory truth claims, she simply chose to disregard one in favor of the other. Whatever gets you through the night, I guess.
            What continues to bother me about this position, one that is held by millions of Christians in the US, is that it is so illogical. It completely disregards the possibility that belief in a creative God might be consistent with discoveries fostered by following the scientific method. Heffernan is perfectly content to compartmentalize her life into sections that do not interact. In doing so she is able to enjoy the benefits of modern scientific discovery – in the form of technology – while completely dismissing anything else such inquiry might discover that explains the world.
            Heffernan is not the only person I know who dismisses the theory of evolution because it doesn’t mesh with her belief in a creator. She is, however, the first I’ve come across to state so baldly that she chooses to live this way because it is more comfortable than the alternative. She freely acknowledges that she is not interested in trying to make all of the pieces fit together.
            The source of the problem for people like Heffernan is that they all tend to read scripture scientifically. By this I mean that they believe that the Bible is not just theologically true, but factually true throughout. In other words, they believe the facts of the Gospel, that God raised Jesus from the dead. Since this is factually true, they expect the Hebrew Scriptures to be factually true as well. Therefore, when Genesis describes a six-day creation story, this must be the facts of how God created the world. As such, when creationists hear of discoveries that do not fit their preconceived understanding of the world, they cast them aside as Heffernan does. Quite frankly, it is easier. Unfortunately, it’s also stupid.
            Reading scripture in this way is stupid precisely because scripture itself does not claim such scientific precision. In his movie Religulous, Bill Maher talks with a Catholic scientist who points out how far removed the world of the scientific method is from the world of the Bible. To expect scientific reporting of the sort we are now accustomed to from the authors of scripture is quite simply senseless.
            Furthermore, individuals who accept the overwhelming evidence in favor of the big bang, et al, see how ludicrous a young earth understanding is. They assume that to be a Christian you must have to turn your brain off and, as a result, are not interested in what Christians might have to say. Yet it is the creator God who gave us minds that allow us to discover the means by which God created the ever-expanding universe. In the very act of shutting off our brains we deny God’s creative goodness to humanity.
            The laws of physics in their most advanced and fantastically intricate mechanics, which human beings are only beginning to understand, can neither prove nor disprove the existence of God. Neither the big bang theory, nor the theory of evolution proves God does not exist. Such is beyond their capacity. Scientific discovery simply explains how things act and appear to be, but cannot explain why. “Why” is the purview of the psychologist, philosopher, or theologian.
            I am a minister precisely because I love the Triune God who has pursued me and has placed upon me a vocational call that I cannot shake. I want others to know the fullness of life available to all people as mediated and facilitated in the power of the Holy Spirit through the atonement of Christ. I just wish Christians would stop putting up so many barriers that keep people from coming to faith.

            The Church has generally done a disservice to people like Heffernan. Of course, to blame “The Church” for failure in this way is to suppose that it is monolithic and speaks with one voice on all topics. Even looking at one specific denomination, such as the ironically named United Methodist Church as it wrestles with issues such as homosexuality in its general conference should demonstrate how naïve this idea is. Still, The Church needs to do a better job of fostering the life of the mind, of scientific inquiry, and thoughtfulness.

Monday, August 12, 2013

Creationists Lack Faith

Insisting that the earth was created in seven literal days reflects a lack of faith and a desire to control God. This is not to say that young-Earthers  have no faith. Clearly they do. Their faith -- specifically, their beliefs -- are so strong that they limit the possibility of knowledge that can be accepted. Stated in another way, what a person believes limits what said individual can accept as knowledge. 

Richard Dawkins, in his book The God Delusion, claimed that people capable of comprehending the scientific realities of the world and discarding faith were "brights." The implication is that those who have faith are dim bulbs, and those who deny evolution are quite frankly burned out. Indeed, criticism of creationists generally stands on the notion that people who believe such things are stupid. 

A person's identity is tied up in his or her belief structure. If one's beliefs are based upon the historicity and factual veracity of the claims of the Bible, regardless of the genre of literature in question, then there is no room in one's mind for contradictory knowledge. Such contradictions are existential threats to one's entire identity and must therefore be resisted or thrown out. While many who hold to these beliefs may not be intellectual giants, they are not all stupid. 

What creationists fail to realize is how small and under their own control their God is. They define God by what they read in scripture and refuse to ask probing questions of the text, or to read one text against others. If they do read in this way, their beliefs predetermine the results. This means that God is only as big as the world revealed in the Bible. Ironically, this means that God is not actually to be seen in his creation unless what we discover fits neatly into the historical, factual confines of the creation stories. If those discoveries do not fit, they are quite simply dismissed as wrong.

But if God is bigger than the confines of scripture, what then? If God did not make clear through the Bible itself that there are vast areas of life and God's activity in it which are not defined there, how can we believe in him? If God did not actually take one week to create the world, can we actually trust that God raised Jesus from the dead? As an existential threat, this is huge. 

For this reason the doors of creationist churches are never opened very wide, at least not for very long. The group huddles close for protection against the threatening world outside, never realizing that the one who lives inside of them is greater and more powerful than the one who lives in the world, since he has conquered the world. If this is not evidence of a lack of faith in God, I don't know what is.

Friday, December 21, 2012

A Christian Frame On Gun Control

It is popular among gun control advocates to claim that the gun in the mind of the second amendment's authors was the muzzle-loaded musket. As such, this is the weapon citizens are constitutionally allowed to keep and bear within a well ordered militia. This is a particularly inane argument. At issue was not the type of weapon, but the use to which the weapons would be put.

The authors wanted to keep the size and cost of the military down so as to keep the populace as free of taxation as possible. This also provided people with protection from an overbearing government, which would otherwise hold a monopoly on military power. If the musket was the only gun in the minds of the authors of the amendment this was because it was the most technologically advanced weapon carried by soldiers the world over. There were also bayonets, swords, horses and artillery in those armies.

The citizen soldiers envisioned in the second amendment would have been similarly armed because they owned all of these weapons. The exception to this would be artillery, which was cost prohibitive for most individuals to possess. Cannon would be held by the militia in its armory. Because of this, they would have been the match of any army in the world.

The authors of the second amendment might be appalled by the size of our standing military and would probably advocate for a return to the militia model to decrease the size and cost of government. Undoubtedly, however, they would not advocate that the populace only be armed with muskets. The overwhelming firepower held by foreign nations, or even by our own government would quickly relegate the people to a state of submission and servitude. This would be completely unacceptable to men like Jefferson, Washington, and etc. As such, they would argue that individuals must be allowed to own modern firearms.

What the framers of the constitution and its amendments would undoubtedly decry are the heinous uses to which these weapons are put. They would also lament the lack of civil responsibility in our society. They believed the freedoms fought for and enshrined in the founding documents must be upheld by citizens serving the best interests of the nation. Their thought was that life and freedom within the United States must ultimately serve the perpetuation of those freedoms. Such an attitude of service seems to be missing, because we serve our individual needs and wants above all others.

The fundamental disagreement Christians should have with all of this is one of lordship. If Christ is Lord, our ultimate service must be to him, instead of the state, our families, or ourselves. Christian actions are to help the Body of Christ advance, irrespective of the needs of the state, or any other organization that claims our loyalty. It is from this perspective that a Christian should approach the question of gun ownership and control.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Evidence of Sin

The variety of responses to the recent tragedy in Newtown, Connecticut all seem to advocate a change in the place guns have in our society. On one side are those who advocate the removal of guns and gun ownership. Or at least the moderation of the type of gun and the ease with which they can be procured. On the other side are those who advocate for gun access to remain the same, or in fact for guns to be more readily available.

Lying behind both arguments is a desire to stop horrendous tragedies like these. The difference is in the way one feels it is best to protect ourselves, our loved ones and our property. This gives a clue as to what actually lies at the heart of both responses. Lurking behind the value or revulsion Americans have for guns is the desire to protect our idols.

Judges 17 & 18 tell the story of Micah and the Danites. Micah creates household gods for himself and hires a levite to be a priest. The priest is there to protect and serve the idols on Micah's behalf, to intercede with the gods on Micah's behalf, and to provide for himself an income. The Danites trying to establish a home for themselves eventually steal the idols, the supporting religious paraphernalia and the priest. They want the priest to do the same for them as he was doing for Micah. And the priest goes along with it. In response, Micah calls out warriors to attack the thieves and get his idols back. Violence ensues among kinfolk because of their lust for these things. Their responses are the natural outcomes of idolatry.

Americans -- and perhaps all people -- believe in the myth of security. We live in the hope that we might be secure and safe from tragedy, misfortune and death. This is one of the reasons we gather things around us. The more we have, the more able we are to keep the forces of evil and chaos away. Of course, all we have really done is re-placed our fears, moving them further away from ourselves. What used to be a fear right up next to us is now outside of our homes. It is as if we are the wealthy fool who says to himself, "You have plenty of grain laid up for many years. Take life easy; eat, drink and be merry" only to learn that his life was to be lost that very night (Luke 12:16-21).

It is a sign of sin in our lives whenever Christians are ruled by and live in fear. Fear represents a heart ruled by avarice, greed, lust and idolatry. Fear demonstrates that we do not actually believe the promises of our redeemer God who says that he will open paradise to us in the afterlife. It tells us that we do not believe that "to live is Christ, to die is gain" (Phil 1:21). It tells us that we hold our things, our attachments, and our own lives as idols ahead of God.

The reality is that no amount of stuff and no amount of weaponry will protect us from the end that is coming for us all. We may delay it for a while, but it is coming. This is not to say that we should simply and fatalistically accept what is coming. Instead, we should look at everything we have as a gift from our gracious God. There is nothing that we have which we did not receive, including our very lives (1 Cor 4:7).

The attitude of the Christian in America should be to acknowledge that we have it good, that we have been blessed, and to use the blessings we have received as a means to bless others. We should work for justice, righteousness, peace, and love. We should strive for health and wholeness for all people: physical, mental, and spiritual health. And we should strive to cast down our idols and all of the things with which we try to protect them.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

I apologized, but...

Further to my post from yesterday, I did apologize. What I apologized for was my lack of civility in interrupting my host. There is no precedent for theological debate or discussion in the group, let alone when someone is sharing a devotion. Whether the speaker's thoughts were mindless drivel, erudite scholarship, or something in between, challenging him at that point was tactless. 

I believe his hermeneutical starting point is fatuous, if not dangerous. The future well-being of individual believers generally and that of the Church in North America specifically are jeopardized by teachings that start from a position which lacks knowledge. 

This is not to say people who hold such positions are stupid. Young Earth advocates simply lack information and refuse to accept it because their faith cannot accommodate what God has given humans the ability to learn about the universe that He created. They do not have room within their faith constructs for such a large God. Yet scripture is full of encouragement to gain knowledge and understanding. All truth is God's truth and we need not fear it. 

The Young Earth hermeneutical starting point creates a barrier to spreading the Gospel. People who are knowledgable about the scientific realities humanity has uncovered will never be interested in joining an apparently mindless organization. The Church becomes nothing more than a backward sub-culture, along the lines of the Amish communities that have a negligible impact upon society, rather than the world-changing counter-culture Jesus left in the care of his disciples. I admire such faith for its apparent strength, yet pity it for its calcified, dogmatic outlook.

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

I know better....


Yesterday I attended a minister’s gathering and was rude to my host. Once most of us had gathered around a table, he opened the proceedings with a devotional thought. He started by lamenting America’s social, political and spiritual atmosphere. He felt that failure to acknowledge that God created marriage to be between a man and a woman, based foundationally on the failure to acknowledge that God created the world in seven days not millions or billions of years as evidenced by Genesis 1-15, was leading to the nation’s moral decline.

“How do you know?” I asked. Spurred on by his surprised “How do I know?” I asked, “How do you know that God created the world in seven literal days instead of millions, or billions of years?”

I know I should have bit my tongue. Since the context was “devotional” not intellectual, it was tantamount to biting the hand that was about to feed me – especially since after the meeting he was feeding the gathered ministers. I created an uncomfortable and awkward period in the proceedings and knew what I had done even as I pressed on. Quite frankly, my back was up so I engaged in debate for a few minutes until others weighed in with calming effect. The train of the devotion derailed, we moved on to other business.

Today an email went out to everyone from the ministerial gathering president:

Hey Gang, I'm going to ask that, in the future, when the host of our meetings presents a devotion, that we respect that devotion.  I'm not saying that you have to agree with what is said, but it isn't an appropriate setting to turn it into a theological debate, nor is it polite considering that we are their guests. At the same time, when planning the devotion, please don't use it as a way to deliberately push an agenda.  Not saying that it needs to be politically correct, but please consider your intentions.

My impression is that the Gospel is an invitation to join the counter-cultural body of Christ. When Church leaders elevate faithful ignorance over informed belief we are not promoting an invitation to an exciting counter-culture where knowledge and intelligence are welcome, but are promoting a sub-culture in which thoughtfulness is unwelcome. Bad theology, informed by illogical hermeneutics, should not go unchallenged if we want to see the Church advance – especially among church leaders.

I find it distasteful to sit through a devotion that is supposed to be edifying to my spirit when it elevates bad information, hermeneutics and theology, and presents it as Gospel. That said, the spirit of the email is correct and I am sorry for my actions. That was neither the time, nor the place for such a debate. Would that Christ really dwelt in me.

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Information Silos

Except for the time in which the human population was so small that there were no divergent opinions (think Adam all alone in the Garden of Eden), there has never been an era in which there has not been some semblance of information siloing. In ages past, information silos existed because the barriers to sharing ideas were geographic.

As webs of interaction grew and geographic barriers fell, opportunities to share information and ideas grew. The silos remained because the interactions were infrequent. As interactions became more frequent, the hope was that information could be shared more frequently, people could learn the same things, and come to the same conclusions. However, lots of different people with different ideas were all working with the same thought on those different ideas. As a result, enclaves and groups with different philosophies grew up and were maintained within their information silos. 

In the present, information silos exist because there is too much information available. People have the ability to filter out and exclude information. Indeed they must do so in order to not become paralyzed through information overload. Observers & commentators frequently lament the existence of these information silos because they reinforce differences. But they also lament the fact that their competitors hold sway in their information silo, so do not have that audience over which to exercise influence, through which to gain more influence, and potentially make more money. And whatever you do, don't let them kid you. It's about the money.





Thursday, November 15, 2012

Work Together


Reviled Chaff-

            Pestilence informs me that his patient is feeling particularly bitter toward your minister. Were you aware of this? If you were, why didn’t you include it in your last report? If not, why not? Aren’t you communicating with your coworkers? You must all work together in order to have the greatest effect on your situation.
            I know what I am about to tell you cuts against every fiber of your being, but you must trust me. When I was a tempter, I was very successful. I know more about how to effectively thwart our enemy and torment souls than you do. If I didn’t I wouldn’t be a manager. And I had a manager over me then, too. He wasn’t as gifted as me, but he was useful. He did for me what I am trying to do for you. I am here to give you ideas for how to proceed that you might not have considered. I can tell you based upon my experience the best method of attack. Another mind working on the problem from a distance gives some objectivity and is able to draw on experiences you do not have. In the unlikely event we run into a big problem that I cannot handle, I can talk with other managers and even go to the superintendent for advice.
            As your superior I could order you to tell me everything that happens, but that would make your reports very tedious. Besides, you should be able to differentiate between what is useful to our cause and what is not. If you demonstrate that you cannot I will have to request a different tempter take your place so that you can return to your last job in the pit. Your file says you were very effective there, which is what allowed you to move up. Still, you would not be the first who was promoted beyond his ability.
            Regardless, I believe you are capable and I assure you that I seek nothing more than your success. So be sure to communicate with your fellows, include useful information in your reports, and remember that you need not fear me. I am here to support you and help you succeed.
            Now, about your minister. Pestilence’s patient believes she finds nothing wrong with homosexuality. Is it true? Does she believe homosexuals are worthy of full inclusion in the church, just as heterosexuals are? This could be dangerous to us. As I told Pestilence, do not proceed with any attack on this issue until we are certain where your charge stands. We must let the animosity and confusion rest for now so that it can do its work.
            This could be very beneficial for us down the road, of course. Human sexuality is one of the great mysteries and is so easily perverted. Fortunately the humans do not understand sexuality either. Even our most experienced investigators have been unable to understand it. What would motivate the enemy to create anything that forces you to give up what is yours? Why would anyone share power? Why would he have filled such a puerile action with sensations that give humans such pleasure? And why were these pleasures given to these lower creatures and not to us as well? Do we not also seek pleasure? I believe this may be a sign that the enemy does not care for the things he made, just as the Evil One says. Why else would he withhold the things that we want from us?
            Regardless, human sexuality has always been something we can use to our advantage. We can pervert it into pain, shame, guilt, fear and inferiority to name just a few of the useful emotions it can bring out. And as our lord tells us, he is the one who twisted the world so that at least some people would disdain members of the opposite sex in favor of the same sex, preventing the birth of more children. How the humans respond to one another on this issue is very entertaining. Sex has done more to ensure we receive souls than any other temptation. In more ways that one! It is probably our enemy’s greatest mistake.
            For now, though, it is best if your minister does not mention sexuality at all. Give Pestilence some time to further harden his charge’s position while beginning to form a faction of people who can oppose the minister openly. As I said before, your operating principle must be to keep them from communicating with one another openly. The longer these divisive feelings are hidden from your minister and the embittered pew-sitter, the greater the effect that can result. So give it time. But do be sure to find out what she believes.

In agony,
Dross

Saturday, November 10, 2012

Gender and Loneliness


Reviled Chaff,

            You are half right. That your minister is female can be an advantage to our cause, but it can also be a tremendous danger. Humans have always valued men over women, so for her to be a success, she must be more talented, more disciplined, and more determined than a man.
            They talk about the equality of the sexes, but women invariably work against barriers men don’t face. As though plumbing were so important. Any weak body possessed by one of our own has tremendous strength. Should this minister stay in contact with our enemy, she can be tremendously dangerous. You could lose the entire population if you are not careful.
            Use the minister’s gender against her. Tell her that the only reason she got this church is because it is a backwater. Remind her that had any man wanted the post, the congregation would undoubtedly have preferred him. And while we are on the subject of “him” remind her that she is a single woman. If she were desirable, attractive, witty enough, etc., etc., she would have a man of her own. Insinuate that she would also have a child of her own if our enemy cared about her. But clearly he doesn’t love her because if he did, she would not be so lonely.
            Be careful to not let this engender pity for the girl. Pity can lead to compassion, a detestable emotion, which promotes sharing and giving. But if she does start to seem pitiable, push her to being pitiful. As she becomes maudlin and overly dramatic the people will withdraw from her. The weaker the relationships she has with the community, the less effect she will have on it. Eventually she will despair and you will have won. Your congregation will realize they are beyond help, that our enemy will never provide them with a competent minister because they are unworthy.
            Here is the plan you should follow. Instill in her a desire to be a savior. Create the illusion that this is the expectation that the congregation has for her. If this is the expectation the congregation has of her, so much the better. Just don’t let them name it. Keep it under the surface. Let it be expressed in statements of comparison with prior pastors from ages ago. Encourage looks of disappointment, but again, don’t let them talk about these things. The moment they start discussing these things, you will have lost your advantage.
            As these expectations work on her, your minister will feel as though she must study more so as to provide better instruction, give the proper answer, etc. Encourage her in this. The more she is shut away in her study, the less likely she is to create relationships. Somehow they gain strength by pouring energy into another person. Such an abnormal activity, and truly frightening! Far more natural to suck energy out of another.
            Regardless, you must also be careful with what she studies. Get her into psychology, politics, economics, or any other work. Keep her as far from the unnameable book as you can. If she must look in it, encourage her to look for proof texts so as to prove her point. Don’t let her draw a point from the text. That will be deadly. Be strong in your efforts, but again, be cunning and subtle.

In agony,
Dross

Friday, November 9, 2012

The Practical Implications of Hermeneutical Lenses

What a person believes is much more important than what a person knows. People approach whatever scriptures they read (the Bible, Quran, Vedas, On the Origin of Species etc.) with hermeneutical lenses already in place. The words people read are understood in light of their innate, natural temperaments and their received, nurtured experiences. Therefore we are all predisposed by what we already understand and believe to come to an interpretation of scripture that is in line with our beliefs. As such the eyeglasses through which we view scripture are equally as important as -- if not more important than -- the scriptures we read.

This postmodern insight confirms that when we approach scripture predisposed to believe that its words are the literal, inerrant, historical and scientific record of God's work in the world, we will leave it believing that scientific discoveries and insights which point in opposite directions are at best in error. At worst we will believe they are deceptions propagated by evil forces, which are in control of those scientists. The implications for human life in the present and future are immense.

Belief necessarily constrains our ability to receive knowledge. For example, the evidence of global warming is ridiculous to those who see an immanent arrival or return of the Messiah on the horizon. Or again, evidence that Jesus lived, and died fits with human experience. We know that people live and die. The testimony of witnesses to Jesus moving among them in the flesh after his death just does not fit. In both cases, the inability to accept the logical testimony of those who say that Jesus rose from the dead, or that the world is warming and human activity is the only logical explanation is not because people are stupid, ignorant, or even uncaring. The issue is the orientating belief structure.

Unless and until people are able to see the lenses through which they view the world, be they theistic or atheistic, scientific or unscientific, they will take sides in the mis-named culture war rather than pursue the truths each "side" knows. Theists will continue to ignore rising temperatures, retreating glaciers, and more devastating natural disasters, while atheists will continue to die without Christ.

Thursday, November 8, 2012

A Station Change


Reviled Chaff-

It was with grave joy that I learned that you and your case had been assigned to me. As I understand it, the previous tempter squandered the years of effort made by demons far more terrible than either of us. He was removed, of course. 
Now, I relish most forms of danger, but the danger we now face nearly defies comprehension. How could that worthless creature have let the people on your new station decide to bring in one of our enemy’s ministers? Didn't he see the warning signs? Undoubtedly not. Most likely he mistook an aspiration for something greater in the minds of those humans as a lack of contentment. He probably even flamed it, assuming that it would lead to wicked ends. I would call him fool, but I do not want to disparage those fools who do well at their craft.
You, however are receiving a great opportunity. As you properly apply the weapons at our disposal we might gain an advantage and return the situation to its natural state of futility. Of course, reinforcements are being reassigned as well, but your direct task is to assail the minister himself. Should you do well your promotion to a role like mine would be next. Stay focused and this can be yours.
I know nothing of your minister so in your next report you must tell me everything you can about him. In this way we can plan our attack more carefully and ensure our success. Since humans are very like us the minister will undoubtedly feel pride at his position. Play upon it. Kindle his pride until it burns like vanity. Once vanity is burning within him, transform it into conceit. Conceit will set his tongue on fire as our enemy knows only too well. Why he gave those lower beings the ability to communicate, placing within their bodies one of our greatest weapons is indeed a mystery. Since it is so easily turned to evil, use it. Let his vanity and conceit produce thoughtless and careless talk. In so doing you will cause hurts to develop, which will drive a wedge between him and the mindless fools who follow.
Use those hurts carefully, however. Do not just let the hurt alone. Help it become a festering wound. If a hurt between two people is not allowed to fester and properly scar, it will only draw the aptly named sheep into a more trusting relationship with their shepherd. When they determine that they must speak about their hurts, as they surely will, let them bleat to one another. They must be made to feel that the minister is not one of them. Keep him an outsider. Highlight what is different about him.
Finally let me remind you of what reflection upon your predecessors errors should have taught you. Moving forward you must be both cunning and subtle. Subtlety alone allows one of our adversary’s angels to turn your evil impulses for good. Cunning is critical. Use it shrewdly and twist aspirations into unreasonable, unattainable desires. Then you will make their hearts sick and more readily distract them with empty pleasures. Do well in this and we will win more souls to our dark feast.

With despair,
Dross

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Freedom and Predestination

To be as committed as Americans are to "freedom" and "individualism" while simultaneously being committed to the Christian ideal that everything is predestined by God is quite irrational.

That is all.